THE CANADIAN DAIRY INDUSTRY

Dairy Cattle Production 342-450A





Importance of the Canadian dairy sector

Dairy is the number one agricultural activity in Quebec with annual income of $1.3 billion in farm cash receipt (~1/3 of the total farm cash receipt). In Quebec, there are about 10,000 dairy producers, 438,000 cows and 182,000 heifers with an annual milk production of  28 millions hL. Quebec is the number one producer of cheese, yogurt and butter and the number two producer of ice cream
Table 1. Dairy farm cash receipts by province (2000).
 
 Province
% of total receipts
Newfoundland 
0.6
Prince Edward Island
1.3
Nova Scotia
2.2
New Brunswick
1.8
Quebec
38.7
Ontario
32.7
Manitoba
3.8
Saskatchewan
2.7
Alberta
7.9
British Columbia
8.3

Structure of the Canadian dairy farms

The Canadian dairy industry is based on 1.2 million cows and 0.5 million heifers (Table 2). More than 80% of Canada's dairy farms are in Quebec and Ontario, 14% in the western provinces and 5% in the Atlantic provinces. The dairy production in Quebec and Ontario accounted for 38.7 and 32.7%, respectively of the total farm cash receipts in 1998.
Table 2. Changes in the number of dairy farms in Canada.

 
 
Year
 
1990
1995
2000
Prince Edward Island
669
485
364
Nova Scotia
686
491
389
New Brunswick
568
407
329
Quebec
14,903
11,782
9.774
Ontario
10,976
8,509
6,918
Manitoba
2,113
1,108
698
Saskatchewan
1,496
763
399
Alberta
2,176
1,272
953
British Columbia
1,031
883
752
Canada ('000 $)
34,620
25,700
20,624

Table 3. Number of cows and (heifers) by province (`000)

 
Year
 
1990
1995
2000
2001
Newfoundland 
4.3 (1.0)
4.5 (0.9)
4.4 (0.8)
4.3 (0.7)
Prince Edward Island
20.3 (8.2
18.3 (7.0)
16.0 (6.8)
16.0 (6.7)
Nova Scotia
33.0 (13.4)
26.9 (11.0)
25.8 (10.0)
25.7 (10.2)
New Brunswick
26.3 (10.2)
22.3 (8.5)
20.5 (8.1)
20.4 (7.9)
Quebec
560.0 (229.4)
507.0 (207.0)
427.0 (178.0)
438.0 (180)
Ontario
460.0 (227.1)
419.0 (189.0)
380.0 (171.0)
386.0 (172)
Manitoba
69.0 (23.0)
56.0 (20.0)
49.5 (15.0)
49.0 (15.0)
Saskatchewan
53.0 (17.0)
44.0 (15.0)
32.0 (14.5)
32.0 (11.0)
Alberta
125.0 (43.0)
98.0 (40.0)
102.0 (37.0)
101.0 37.0)
British Columbia
78.0 (27.5)
78.0 (30.0)
84.5 (27.0)
83.5 (28.5)
Canada
1,428.9 (599.8)
1,274.0 (528.4)
1,141.7 (468.2)
1,155.9 (469.0)

Table 4. Average production of Canadian dairy cows by province (1999).

Province
Milk (kg)
Fat (%)
Fat kg)
Protein (%)
Protein (kg)
Maritimes
8,680
3.68
319
3.19
277
Ontario
8,892
3.72
331
3.25
289
Quebec
8,852
3.75
332
3.25
288
Manitoba
8,815
3.62
319
3.29
290
Saskatchewan
9,083
3.53
321
3.25
295
Alberta
9,473
3.54
335
3.21
304
British Columbia
9,483
3.61
342
3.22
305

Milk and Other Dairy Products
There are two markets for milk in Canada
1- Fluid milk market: Includes table milk and fresh cream (39% of the total milk production). 

2- Industrial milk market: Includes milk used for manufacturing dairy products such as cheese, butter, and ice cream (61% of the market). 

Despite the fact that most of the milk sold in Canada is industrial milk, the ratio of fluid:industrial milk varies from one province to another (Figure). For instance, more than 80% of the milk sold in Quebec is industrial milk while more than 60% of the milk sold in BC is fluid milk. 

Fluid milk sales in 1999-2000 totaled 2.7 billion liters. The 2% fat milk accounted for 51% of total fluid milk sales while homogenized milk 3.25% fat) accounted for 16% of the total fluid milk sales. Specialty milk products (e.g. microfiltered products, calcium enriched milk, lactose free milk) are gaining popularity. More than 50% of the industrial milk is used for the manufacturing of cheese. The total amount of fluid milk sold in Quebec in 1999-2000 was 6.5 million hL (24% of the fluid milk sales in Canada).  The 2% milk accounted for 59% of the fluid milk sales in Quebec. 

Most of the industrial milk (~60%) sold in Canada is used for cheese production. The total cheese production in Canada in 1999-2000 was 326,000 tons with cheddar accounting for 40% of total cheese production (Figure). Canada's production of specialty cheese in 1999-2000 was 193,598 tons with mozzarella accounting for 59% of the total specialty cheese production (Figure). Quebec is the main cheese producer in Canada, accounting for 50 and 58%  of total cheddar and specialty cheese production, respectively. Quebec is also the leading province in butter and yogurt production (38 and 48%, of the total production, respectively) while Ontario remains the leading ice cream producer in Canada (48% of total production). 


Consumption of Dairy Products in Canada
The per capita consumption of fluid milk in 2000 was 85 liters. Consumption of 3.25 and 2% fat milk is on the decline while that of 1% fat milk and skim milk continues to rise. Consumption of other dairy products is shown in Table 4 (see Figure).

 

 

 

 

 

Table 4. Per capita consumption of dairy products in Canada (2000).

Milk product
Amount
Fluid milk (liter)
85
Cheese
11.6
Butter (kg)
2.9
Cream (liter)
6.4
Ice cream (liter)
8.8
Yogurt (kg)
4.9

Export and Import of Canadian Dairy Products
Due to the adoption of the supply management system, The contribution of the Canadian dairy industry to the international dairy market in minimal. However, due to the WTO ruling the import of dairy products into Canada is increasing.  Exports of Canadian dairy products totaled $287 millions in 2000 (Figure). Export products include butter, milk powder, condensed milk (to developing countries) and specialty cheese and ice cream (to developed countries). Exports of Canadian genetic materials (cows, embryos and semen) were $128 million (Figure). Major export markets include United Kingdom, USA, Mexico, and Japan. 
Canadian dairy product imports include cheeses (56%), casein (12%), and whey (12%). The dairy imports totaled $457 millions in 2000 (Figure). Suppliers of imported dairy products to Canada include the European union (42%), USA (27%) and New Zealand (19%). The Canadian trade balance for dairy products has changed from a surplus of $67 millions in 1996 to a deficit of $170 millions in 2000 (Figure). 
Go to Top of Page


The Canadian Supply Management System

Introduction

The Canadian milk market is primarily supplied by domestic production, with small volumes of imported dairy products (cheese, butter and yogurt). Dairy products in excess of the domestic market are exported either directly by the Canadian Dairy Commission or by the private sector. Canada accounts for about 1-2% of the dairy products traded in the international market (Figure).

Supply Management System
The Canadian national dairy policy is based on three key elements: 
1- National milk supply management system. 

2- Control of dairy product imports through tariff rate quotas. 

3- Federal price subsidies

·The supply management system is employed by the dairy industry in Canada to provide a balance between the supply of industrial milk and the demand for dairy products based on butterfat usage. The system was adopted in the early seventies to enhance income stability for dairy producers and to reduce market unstability. 

·The Canadian Dairy Commission pays subsidy directly to the producers on deliveries of industrial milk. Subsidy on qualifying shipments of industrial milk and cream is $0.844 per kg of butterfat. In the early nineties, the subsidy was $6 per hL of milk (3.6% MF) and has dropped to $0.76 per hL in 2001.  This subsidy will be eliminated by the year 2002. There is no limit to the amount of milk a producer can deliver in excess to their quotas. However, producers will receive world price for production exceeds quotas. 

·In order to maintain stability to the national milk supply management system, Canada has placed several restrictions to minimize the import of dairy products. However, these restrictions changed in 1995 as a result of the World Trade Organization Agreement on Agriculture, which moved Canada into a much more global market place and opens the door for more imported dairy products. The imported dairy products are first received by the Canadian Dairy Commission and then sold to processors for further processing in a manner design to minimize adverse effects of domestic market. 


 

The Canadian Dairy Commission (CDC)

The CDC is a federal corporation, which plays a central role in the Canadian dairy industry. The CDC is funded by the federal government, dairy producers and the marketplace.


Duties of the CDC

- Administration of the federal subsidy to dairy producers (peaked at $280 million in 1987). 
- Calculation of the Market Sharing Quota

- Administration of pooling agreements on behalf of dairy producers. 

- Determination of support prices at which it will purchase butter and skim milk powder. 

- Works with the private sector to balance the seasonal demand and supply of dairy products. 

- Acts as the first receiver of imported butter. 

- Exports Canadian dairy products either directly on a government to government basis or through Canadian exporters. 

- Provides technical support to provincial boards and the CMSMC (chairman of the CMSMC).
Go to Top of the Page


The Canadian Milk Supply Management Committee (CMSMC)
Overseas the application of the National Milk Marketing Plan. The CMSMC has representation from the producers and all provinces (except Newfoundland). Representatives of consumer, processor and producer organizations are also members (non-voting) of the CMSMC. Each year, the CMSMC sets the national Market Share Quota (MSQ) for industrial milk and establishes the share of each province in the MSQ (Table 1).


 

 

 

 

 

 

Table 1. Market Sharing Quota by province for the year 2000.

 
Butterfat 

(million kg) 

3.6% milk 

(million hectoliters) 

%
Prince Edward Island
3.009
0.836
1.8
Nova Scotia
2.023
0.562
1.2
New Brunswick
2.043
0.568
1.3
Quebec
77.044
21.401
47.3
Ontario
51.055
14.182
31.3
Manitoba
5.631
1.546
3.5
Saskatchewan
4.460
1.239
2.7
Alberta
10.220
2.839
6.3
British Columbia 
7.454
2.070
4.6
Canada
162.939
44.261
100.0

Source: Canadian Dairy Commission

Each province allocates its share of the MSQ to its producers according to its own policies. Supply management takes into account the domestic demand for industrial milk, certain imports and some production, which is shipped to export markets. Estimates of MSQ are based on : 

- Previous year's domestic consumption. 

- Anticipated changes in demand. 

- Projected dairy product stocks. 

- Import commitments. 

- Export obligations 

A safety margin (currently 1.2%) known as the sleeve, is added to estimated MSQ to absorb unexpected increases in demand. Milk surpluses are managed trough quota and stock adjustment, and export programs. In 1995, the Canadian dairy industry adopted a new system for pricing and pooling of market return. Under this system, industrial milk is classified and made available for use in dairy products at prices, which vary according to the end use of the milk.

Go to the Top of the Page


Fluid milk
The supply and price of fluid milk is determined at the provincial level (provincial milk boards) depending on consumption of fluid milk within that province. Fluid milk quota is the number of liters per day a producer is entitled to deliver and receive premium prices for that portion of sales in the month. Fluid milk quota is issued in 5-liter portions. There is no federal subsidy for fluid milk. 
The blend price paid to producers is the weighted average of fluid milk, industrial milk and over quota on monthly basis. In addition, producers can contract with processing plants for optional export program milk at world prices 

Inter provincial marketing pools


Farm gate prices of milk

Farm gate milk prices are set by the provincial milk boards based on cost of production estimates. The prices been based on milk volume or weight and fat percentage. Historically, a bonus has been paid for milk fat production above 3.6%. However, provinces are moving towards a Multiple Component Pricing System (MCP) where protein will be priced higher than fat (110%) and other solids at 20% of protein. Payments for the MCP will be set by the CDC. 

Upcoming changes in the Canadian dairy policy
- Phase out of the direct payment subsidies (gone by 2002). Support will be indirect (e.g. genetic improvement and research). 
- Export subsidies to processors and exporters will be removed and surplus milk paid for at world prices. 
- Imports of dairy products will be less restricted. 

- Quota will move from fat only to multiple component price for fat, protein and other solids. 

- Raw and processed fluid and industrial milk will move freely across provincial borders (now only industrial products move freely. 

Go to the Top of the Page


ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Information included in the above document was compiled from the following sources